In a competitive job market, employee retention is closely tied to fair compensation. When workers feel underpaid, morale drops, productivity suffers, and turnover increases. Addressing underpaid employee requests quickly and effectively is essential for both individual satisfaction and organizational health.
This guide will explain how employees can request a raise when they believe they are underpaid and how employers can respond to such requests professionally.
What Does It Mean to Be Underpaid?
An employee is considered underpaid when their compensation is below the market rate for similar roles, their experience level, and geographic location.
Common causes include:
- Outdated salary structures
- Lack of performance-based adjustments
- Inflation outpacing wage growth
- Pay disparities compared to peers
Signs You Might Be Underpaid
- Your salary hasn’t increased in several years despite added responsibilities
- Job listings for similar roles offer significantly higher pay
- Coworkers with similar experience earn more
- You consistently exceed performance expectations without pay recognition
How Underpaid Employees Can Request a Raise
Research Your Market Value
Use resources like:
- Glassdoor
- PayScale
- LinkedIn Salary Insights
- Bureau of Labor Statistics
This helps you back your request with data.
Document Your Contributions
List:
- Achievements
- Revenue you’ve generated or costs you’ve saved
- Positive client feedback
- Additional skills acquired
Choose the Right Timing
- After a major project success
- During performance reviews
- When the company is performing well financially
Prepare Your Request Script
Example:
“Based on my research, the market rate for my position in this area is [X% higher] than my current salary. Considering my recent contributions to [specific projects], I’d like to discuss adjusting my compensation to reflect my value to the company.”
Stay Professional
Keep the tone positive and focus on your value, not just dissatisfaction.
How Employers Should Respond to Underpaid Employee Requests
Listen Without Dismissing
Acknowledge the concern and avoid defensive responses.
Review Market Data
Compare the employee’s current salary to industry averages and competitors.
Evaluate Performance
Assess whether the employee’s contributions justify a salary adjustment.
Offer Transparency
If an immediate raise isn’t possible, explain why and provide a clear timeline for review.
Consider Alternatives
Offer temporary perks such as:
- Bonuses
- Flexible schedules
- Professional development opportunities
Why Addressing Underpayment is Critical
- Retention – Replacing an employee can cost 50–200% of their annual salary.
- Morale – Fair pay motivates higher productivity.
- Reputation – Companies that underpay risk negative employer branding.
Mistakes Employees Should Avoid When Requesting a Raise
- Comparing yourself to colleagues in a confrontational way
- Threatening to quit without a backup plan
- Making the request during a company financial crisis
- Failing to provide evidence of your market value
Best Practices for Employers to Prevent Underpayment Issues
- Conduct annual salary reviews
- Adjust for inflation and market trends
- Maintain transparent pay policies
- Reward high performers promptly
Example Email for Requesting a Salary Review
Subject: Request for Salary Review
Hi [Manager’s Name],
I appreciate the opportunities I’ve had to contribute to [Company Name], particularly in [specific projects]. Based on my research of current market rates and my recent contributions, I’d like to request a salary review to ensure my compensation reflects my role and performance.
I’d be happy to discuss this at a time convenient for you.
Best regards,
[Your Name]
Conclusion
An underpaid employees request for fair pay is not just about money—it’s about recognition, respect, and value. Employees should approach the conversation with research, professionalism, and clear evidence of their contributions. Employers should respond with transparency and a willingness to address disparities.
When handled well, these conversations can strengthen trust, boost morale, and improve long-term retention for the organization.
FAQs
1. How do I know if I’m underpaid?
Compare your salary with industry data for your role, location, and experience level.
2. Should I mention other job offers in my request?
Only if you are prepared to follow through—this can be risky.
3. What if my employer refuses my raise request?
Ask for a timeline for future consideration and explore skill-building opportunities.
4. Can I request a raise outside of my performance review?
Yes—especially if you’ve recently taken on more responsibilities or achieved significant results.
5. How much should I ask for if I’m underpaid?
Typically, 5–15% above your current salary, depending on market data and your contributions.
Also read: Warehouse Inventory Tracking: Methods, Tools & Best Practices for 2025
